To Gauge or Not to Gauge?

I have a confession – I love doing a gauge swatch before starting a new project. Did I just hear a groan? But it is true. I find swatching relaxing and therapeutic. I know for a lot of knitters the excitement of a new knitting project is too much and they must start the project immediately. I see the gauge swatch as the start of the project. To me it is essential to the success of the final project. I firmly believe – No I KNOW – that the 3 essential elements of knitting – yarn, needles and hands – are different each time you use them. Let me explain. The excitement of a new project can make a usually tight knitter more loose and a usually loose knitter more tight. This can make for some interesting knitting. Also needles – wood, metal, or plastic – make a difference with  the yarn. Knitting the gauge swatch is like a concert pianist practicing a new piece. Even if you have used that yarn before with those needles, the stitch pattern can throw you off. Swatching is my chance to get it right before I start the main event.

And I swatch big. Depending on the project, I usually knit a 5 to 6 inch square swatch. Even if the gauge only calls for a 1 inch swatch, I need to see the pattern over a larger area. I need to get the pattern in my fingers. But I never save my swatches. I live in fear of running out of yarn at the end of the project even though it has never happen. I frog the swatch after knitting it if I get the right gauge. So from this day forward, I’m going to save my swatches so I will have beautiful “catalog” of mini-projects!


  1. Oh, you went there with a controversial one… ;-).I never swatch and the reason I don't is I did once and then when I started the project the gauge came out different to the swatch (same yarn and needles). No clue why that was, but now I just start the project and assess after an inch or so and then frog/ reknit if necessary. It's not a great system but I'm starting to be able to produce things that are meant to actually fit, and NOT JUST SCARVES ;-).


  2. Yes, I went there! :)I know swatching is not for everyone and I've had the same issue you have had with it all coming out wrong in the end. I guess swatching for me is less about gauge and more about getting the practice in on the stitch pattern.Thanks for commenting!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s